Best Italian Restaurants in The Villages: Our Top Pick is Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza

Searching for the best Italian restaurants in The Villages? It can feel like hunting for a needle in a haystack. While many spots serve Italian-inspired food, not all deliver authentic flavor, fresh ingredients, and top-tier service.

After trying a variety of local Italian restaurants, one stood out: Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza in Lake Deaton Plaza.

Looking for more new spots across The Villages? Don’t miss our full guide to Eastport restaurants & entertainment , one of the biggest upcoming dining areas south of 44.

Piesanos: Among the Best Italian Restaurants in The Villages

Piesanos may be a chain, but don’t let that fool you. This location on Kristine Way continually exceeds expectations. In fact, it ranks among the best Italian restaurants in The Villages for good reason.

As soon as you walk in, you’re welcomed by a vibrant atmosphere and the mouthwatering smell of a stone-fired oven. But what makes it truly stand out? It’s the combination of quality, consistency, and service.

Stone-Fired Perfection: Their pizzas feature crisp crusts, fresh toppings, and rich flavor. Whether you like a classic Margherita or a specialty pie, the stone-fired method delivers.
More Than Pizza: They serve hearty pasta, tasty appetizers, and crisp salads. The Chicken Parmesan is a standout. Every item reflects their commitment to fresh ingredients.
Consistency Matters: Unlike many places, Piesanos gets it right every time. Dishes arrive hot, well-prepared, and full of flavor.
Great Service: Friendly, attentive staff make each visit enjoyable. You’re never left waiting long.
Recipe for Success: Great food, a welcoming vibe, and efficient service keep guests coming back.

Piesanos Is Growing — And That’s Good News

Here’s some exciting news: Piesanos is opening a second location in Southern Trace Plaza. That means more access to one of the best Italian restaurants in The Villages. It’s a great sign of their growing popularity.

What Makes an Italian Restaurant Truly Great?

Of course, taste is personal. Yet a few things make Italian places rise above the rest. These include:

Fresh ingredients — always the starting point.
Authentic flavors — traditional or with a modern twist.
Proper seasoning — not too much, not too little.
Texture — perfectly cooked pasta, crispy crusts, tender meats.
Ambiance — cozy, relaxed, or upscale, depending on the mood.
Friendly staff — service that feels warm and welcoming.

What’s Your Favorite Italian Spot in The Villages?

Piesanos is our top pick right now, but things change. Maybe your favorite is different! We’d love to hear your thoughts.

Have you tried Piesanos? What did you think?
Know another hidden gem for Italian cuisine? Check out our full restaurant guide here.
What makes a place your personal favorite?

Let us know in the comments. We’re always looking to discover more of the best Italian restaurants in The Villages.

Also, don’t miss our full list of top restaurant picks in Brownwood.

Learn more about Piesanos and their menu on their official website.