The 5 Best Restaurants in Spanish Springs (Ranked by Locals)

Plan a Night Out Around the Best Restaurants in Spanish Springs

The best restaurants in Spanish Springs offer a unique mix of charm, comfort, and flavor that feels like Old Florida with a Villager twist. Whether you’re heading out for a date night, live music, or just a casual bite after golf, Spanish Springs Town Square has something delicious waiting for you.

Here are five local favorites in and around the square — all chosen for their food, atmosphere, and popularity among Villagers who know a good meal when they see one.

1. Bella Vita Italian Steakhouse — Best for Date Night

Elegant, inviting, and perfect before a show.

This upscale spot near the square serves classic Italian fare alongside premium steaks and seafood. It’s a favorite for Villagers heading to an evening performance at The Sharon Theater — making it the ideal place to enjoy a glass of wine and a great meal before the show.

2. Ruby Tuesday – The Villages — Best Burger Specials in the Square

Affordable, reliable, and packed with weekly deals.

Ruby Tuesday is a go-to for great weekly specials that locals love. Every Tuesday, select burgers and sandwiches are just $6.99, making it one of the best value meals around the square.

On Thursdays, they roll out what many call the “best deal of the week”: a Single American Smashed Burger and Endless Garden Bar for just $8.99. It’s casual, consistent, and friendly — everything you want in a neighborhood spot.

3. Amerikanós Grille — Best Patio for Live Music

Front-row seat to the square’s entertainment.

Located right on the edge of the square, Amerikanós is a great place to grab a Mediterranean-inspired meal and enjoy the live music happening nightly. Locals love the open-air dining and lively atmosphere.

4. Coastal Del Mar — Best Seafood Experience

Upscale coastal cuisine in a stylish setting.

Just a short stroll from the square, Coastal Del Mar brings a polished seafood-forward menu to The Villages. A great pick for seafood lovers looking for a refined experience near Spanish Springs.

5. Ay! Jalisco — Best Authentic Mexican

A long-standing local favorite with serious flavor.

Ay! Jalisco continues to draw crowds for its authentic dishes and colorful atmosphere. It’s a reliable choice when you’re craving Mexican near the square.

Looking for More of the Best Restaurants in Spanish Springs?

Explore our weekly restaurant picks or check out nearby squares like Brownwood or Lake Sumter Landing for even more dining options.

Plan Your Night Out

Pair your meal with one of the many events happening nightly in Spanish Springs — from classic car nights to dancing under the stars. Check the Villages events calendar to see what’s happening.

These are just a few of the best restaurants in Spanish Springs, but there’s always something new to try.